Tuesday, February 28, 2023

A Brightly Marked Path

 If you choose to follow your own path in life, expect to be lost a good part of the time.

Becoming a teacher was not the path that was marked out for me. 

There were other brightly-marked paths. Engineering, for example: my dad, two of my uncles, two of my cousins were engineers and it seemed an obvious choice to me. My friend Bob became an engineer. We were Bar Mitzvah together. We were lab partners in high school for three years in chemistry, physics, and organic chemistry. His dad, like mine, was an engineer. They knew each other from college. But I didn't choose that path.

When I was 17 I was completely without direction. I talked a lot about not going to college, which was anathema in my family, community, social strata, etc. I thought I could stay in the warehouse where I was employed during holidays and eventually drive a truck. I remember my mom weeping and shouting about this ambition. One day my dad saw an old Chevy pickup for sale and suggested my brother and I buy it, fix it up, and travel around in it together. If you have never seen the Sierra Club book On the Loose it will give you an idea of the romantic note this struck for me. If you know that book, well, you already know. But don't take it out and look at it again. I, at least, am always disappointed. In any case, Mom went into a paroxysm of tears and accusations. Dad said not a word.

So I found myself seeing a vocational counselor. I didn't yet know the origin of the word "vocation" in the idea of a calling, as in being called to prophesy. But I was impressed by the magic of multiple-choice interest index assessments, especially sticking a pin in the paper instead of bubbling in a scantron. I imagined being struck by the power of what would be revealed for me. Instead, the counselor revealed triumphantly that I could be a... Doctor! I matched successful and happy doctors with a desire to care for others and I had aptitude in math and science. To me, this was a giant let down. I had less-than-no interest in this, I suspect because it was a cliché, such a cliché. Every smart Jewish boy who was good at science could make everyone proud and be a draw for the girls (and their ambitious moms) by going to med school. When I was in my forties I realized that I could have been a good doc, but at 17 it was the last thing on my mind.

Another road that had lights shining on it was the one that led to becoming an attorney. If you were a smart Jewish boy who wasn't  good at science, the obvious choice was law school. When I try to count the numbers of friends and classmates who became lawyers - high school and college, Jewish and not - I don't know where to start. It seems easier to count those who did not. And the appeal was obvious. When I was in high school we sued the school superintendent over our First Amendment right to create and distribute our own independent publications. Our pro bono attorney was the mom of a student at the school, but she was also a clinical professor at Rutgers Law School. She made us do our own legal research and draft our own briefs. I really loved that work. My absolutely favorite part was at the hearing which came three years after we initiated the case, when I was already a freshman in college. Our lawyer was questioning the superintendent and he launched into his customary bloviation instead of answering her questions. The hearing examiner, who was the Chancellor for the State of New Jersey, just cut him off and told him to confine himself to responding to what he was asked. A triumph! But not enough to make me turn myself into another cliché.

So why school? Most people who become teachers love school and want to be like a teacher they had. I'm from that minority who go into education to fix their own experience. I'll go into some detail about this, because I really did like learning and books. I had a couple of teachers in elementary school who encouraged exploration, a couple. In second grade I would closely watch other kids who were engaged in what was called "seat work." As soon as the first ones finished I would jump up as if I, too, had done anything at all, and work with the prisms, hand lenses, weather instruments, tuning forks, etc. that enriched that classroom. In sixth grade I hand copied scenes from the scripts of Broadway plays and enlisted classmates to act them out. I have no memory at all of what I was supposed to be doing instead, but that teacher didn't seem to care. 

But that was two teachers. Most years the teachers were all about compliance. I was locked in supply closets to stop me from talking to my neighbors. My desk was overturned repeatedly because it wasn't neat. Once I was even put in a garbage can for that same offense. In third grade the teacher sent me to sit in a sixth grade class while the big kids laughed at me. I chose to pay attention to them reading aloud from their science book about the parts of the ear and the parts of the eye. I had no idea what I was even being punished for. It was only many years later, as an adult and a teacher myself, that I learned that this was meant to be enrichment! As if listening to someone reading aloud from a text book was actual science education. I have told elsewhere the story of the fifth-grade teacher who gave us fifty nights of homework he called "study guides" on each state. I eventually discovered that these sheets were completed by copying directly from the World Book Encyclopedia, an expensive reference work my family did not own and a fact he never divulged.

A moment's digression on the subject of punishment for unknown offenses: In junior high school that experience was just endless. It seemed that because I was known for talking too much I was given detention every time anyone in the class spoke out of turn. In ninth grade I never left on time because I had detention every day. Once I fell from the rings in gym class and broke my arm. I got detention for that, too. 

The worst incident has stayed with me and I have told the story over and over. The assistant principal called me in and ordered me to clean all the halls in the school every day for a week after classes were let out. I asked what I had done to deserve this, so he blew up and shouted that he would tell me at the end of the week. When I met the custodian who was (angrily) supervising my work I discovered that he was providing me with a rolling garbage can, but not with a broom. They expected me to do this work with my fingers. 

And I did. Everyday for a week I carefully picked up every scrap in the long halls of both stories of the building which served about a thousand kids. At the end of the week I went to ask that assistant principal to, please, tell me what offense I had committed. He blew up again, opened his desk drawer, pulled out a fat sheaf of papers, and slammed them down on his desk, yelling, "Next time be more careful about where you throw your garbage!" But they weren't mine. They belonged to another boy with a similar name. And I said so. He ignored that. I stood waiting for... an apology? an acknowledgment of any kind? But he studiously ignored me for a long few minutes. And then he shouted at me to get out of his office. 

I thought about this experience a lot when I became an assistant principal thirty-five years later. But the "learning" in that school was no better. In every subject, the expectation was just to repeat what the teachers told us. Sometimes we were even held accountable for things they hadn't yet said. Our ninth-grade biology teacher, for example, spent precious class time every week berating us for being "behind." She would inventory all the units we had "covered"* and those we hadn't yet gotten to. And she kept telling us that the most important unit was genetics, which would be the last one. We never got to that unit on genetics before the year ended. But our final exam consisted of one hundred multiple-choice questions and fifty of them were about genetics. Fortunately, for me I had already cultivated enough contempt for our teachers that I spent two nights studying the section of the textbook on genetics. I killed that exam.

Things didn't change much in high school. If we were asked for "Four Causes of the Civil War" we could lose points twice for including one that the teacher hadn't mentioned: once for leaving one of hers out, once for adding one of our own. Our final exam in Qualitative Analysis consisted of a practical, identifying an unknown. My partner and I carefully did those tests. When we got a different answer than we were supposed to, our grade was lowered, because there was no way that teacher could acknowledge that she had been less careful and that the sample had oxidized.

The emphasis on conformity had only gotten worse, too. One day I came in carrying two guitars - electric and acoustic - along with a large amplifier, in addition to my books. One of the assistant principals (the nice one!) stopped me in the hall to ask what I was forgetting. I had no idea. I thought maybe he thought I should have greeted him: "Good morning, Mr. Winter?" I asked. No, that wasn't it. He wanted me to put everything down so that I could take off my hat, because, you know, no hats in the building. 

Another day I got called in to the office of one of the other APs who said - I swear - "I've got you now!" And what did he have me for? An overdue library book, which was, in fact, not overdue; which was, in fact, on the library shelf where it belonged. 

Their need for conformity crossed the line into paranoia because this was the sixties. Friends were removed from the crew doing morning announcements for saying the word "cheese" on the PA. Our confident administrators thought this was the signal for a student uprising. The editors of the school paper were fired for publishing a photo of the wrapped presents for a Christmas toy drive. The toys were stored - and the photo taken - in a locked girls' room. (Yes, most of the bathrooms were kept locked to deal with the cigarette problem, and yes, we had to guess which one was open on any given day.)  Anyway, if you knew to look you could discern a white spot on the wall behind the smiling volunteers holding up packages, and if you knew what you were looking for you might realize that it was a tampon dispenser. So the editors who allowed this pornography obviously had to go. I brought this up in student council, so I was removed from the journalism class and had to spend the rest of the year sitting in the guidance suite during that period.

But the height of their paranoia went on display in the spring of my senior year. The incident came to be called a walkout and the class of '70 remembers ourselves as "The Class that Walked Out." Here's what I remember: A week earlier the elected student leaders invited some of us to join them in organizing a morning meeting to discuss the administration's negative response to a long list of requests we had made on subjects ranging from dress code to leaving the building for lunch. (We were allowed to leave for lunch when we were in elementary school. Why should we be held captive now that we were in high school?) The immediate trigger for the officers of the student government was less serious than many others, their suggestion that final exams not be weighed so heavily. But it was the first time the principal actually said "No" instead of asking for more time to study the question. It was also the first time he called us "ants" and said that our opinions were irrelevant. 

So the next morning we called everyone to attention in the cafeteria where students gathered before classes on days when the weather was less than perfect. We updated the people who were there on the situation and expressed our disappointment and anger. 

The administration's response (because how could they possibly not respond to this breach of decorum!?) was to change the day's schedule in order to have three assemblies, one for each grade, where they could tell the students THE TRUTH and counter THE LIES we had told. That plan changed immediately after the first assembly because the sophomores responded to the administration's TRUTH with catcalls and shouted contradictions. Not only were there no assemblies for juniors and seniors, but now THE TRUTH was that none had ever been planned! 

That was a Friday. By Monday the faculty had all been briefed on lockdowns and lock ins and the code words that would trigger them, as well as on the need to provide intelligence on student plans (of which we had none) to the administration. They also implemented a "rumor clinic" where students could go to find out THE TRUTH. Of course, everybody who went in to check out something they heard told us that the immediate response - to everything - was, "Who told you that?" Because it was another ploy to find out our "plans."

That Thursday an eleventh-grade boy stood up in front of the cafeteria before class with a paper and said that he wanted to share some thoughts. Immediately every cafeteria door flew open and the male teachers ran in. (Who knows how long they had been waiting to put on this bully-boy display?) Some of them grabbed that junior boy and hustled him out, but most of them just started pushing everybody outside into the parking lot. Everything else that happened afterwards is significant, too, but it is a story for another time. I will just report that the AP who "got me" for an overdue library book set his sights that morning on catching me, chasing me around the cafeteria and yelling until I hopped a table and escaped upstairs to my homeroom.

Am I conveying the story of a boy who loved school? Who loved his teachers and wanted to grow up to be like them?

My college definitely did not encourage a career in teaching, either. Some schools have a whole education department, or at least a program. We did not. By a series of missteps and coincidences during my freshman year I ended up taking an advanced-level course in the Sociology of Urban Education. I hadn't done the (multiple!) prerequisites because I was a first year student. The readings themselves were interesting, but I really loved the requirement that we spend a few hours a week at a public elementary school in the West 80's. I mean I loved it because it was real work, off-campus, with people who I would otherwise not have met. And it got me thinking, because I still had no career goal. Why had my education been so sterile? What if I worked as a teacher when I graduated college, at least until I figured out what my actual calling was?

I said above that my college actively discouraged this thinking. I went to the dean and asked if I could take a summer course at a college that did prepare teachers. He laughed, said that I would receive no credit for attending such a school, but promised that he would arrange for me to do student teaching during my senior year. It is not a spoiler at this late date to reveal that when that time came he insisted that he did not make such a promise, could not have made such a promise, and did not remember ever having had a conversation of any kind with me. 

I think these are enough shitty memories for one morning. I'll come back to this another day.



*That notion of "coverage" is one of the stupidest things educators talk about, as if you have actually taught anything because you said it or assigned reading about it. I think its best to understand them as meaning "cover" in the sense of "obscure" as in covering something with a blanket, or covering up a crime.

Thursday, February 16, 2023

School Choice

School choice sounds like a no-brainer, right? What could possibly be wrong about giving parents the opportunity to choose the best school for their child?

It doesn't take much of a second glance to see how the advocates of choice have been waging war on all public education for over forty years that I know about. 

Consider the state of Arizona. In 2011 the legislature created a $2.5 million program for children with special needs that weren't being served adequately by their public school. The children were given vouchers to pay for private schools that would provide appropriate services.* In New York, special-needs children who can show that they are not receiving appropriate services are given a Nickerson Letter, which guarantees that the state will pay their private school tuition. In New York, affluent parents who can afford attorneys who specialize in this area of the law find it much easier to obtain those letters than other parents. In both states it is very difficult in practice to actually find private schools that will serve more difficult cases. We personally visited several very impressive schools, especially designed for children with special needs, and charging astronomical tuitions, who balked at serving children on the autism spectrum. 

But Arizona's voucher law was never really intended to help the parents of children with special needs. It was transparently intended as a foot in the door to normalize the practice of vouchers in order to give them to other parents, especially richer parents. It is now "universal" meaning available to anybody, or at least anybody who can afford the balance of a private school tuition after the value of the voucher, and who can get their child into one of those private schools.

Just in the first quarter of this 2022-2023 school year Arizona spent $300 million on vouchers, or 120 times the original cost of the program. More important, 80% of that money went to families that were already sending their children to private schools! In other words, Arizona robbed $240 million from public schools and from the children who attend them. This is a give-away to the affluent families that send their children to private school. It is a gift to the private schools themselves, especially the for-profit private schools. It is a giant step toward segregating schools by race and by social class since private schools can exclude anyone they want.

I have said many times that privatizing a public service serves at least three purposes. First, ideological. There are so many people who believe that there is no "we", that none of us is ever responsible for or to anyone but ourselves. This is a fraudulent ideology. It denies facts about our personal lives in which all of us are mutually dependent and it denies facts about human history in which all of our progress has been collective.

Second, it is a way to transfer money from the have-nots to the haves. Rich people get to lower their own taxes by refusing to pay for anyone else's needs, even when they - the rich - actively create those needs, as in cutting corners on environmental and workplace safety (or spilling toxic chemicals into public water supplies) to increase their profit margins. And in the case of school funding, they take it for their own kids. Instead of getting a public education for their children, poor people pay taxes to support the tuition of wealthy kids in private schools.

Third, it is always (always!) an invitation to corruption. The rapid and barely-regulated expansion of charters has given us so many examples of "schools" that didn't exist except on paper or were led by people with no educational experience and - in some cases - no education at all! The idea that the profit motive is a stimulus for excellence and efficiency is a story that we have been sold. Profits can be increased to 100% of revenue by the simple method of reducing costs to zero: providing us with nothing at all in return for what we pay.

Now the Texas legislature is considering a universal voucher program, which would give every parent reimbursement for private school tuition, whether in-person or online. In the Texas Observer article linked below, Josephine Lee calculates a $3 billion loss to Texas public schools if this law is passed. On the face of it, that makes sense. If parents vote with their feet by taking their children out of the public schools, why should they have that money? 

But look again. Despite its wealth, Texas is among the stingiest states in per pupil funding, under $10,000 per pupil per year. That 10K won't go far in allowing a poor family in Dallas, say, to send their children to Good Shepherd Episcopal, with its $24,000 a year tuition. But it is a windfall to the parents who already send their children there. And that $3 billion figure is not for an exodus of children from public to private schools. It is the cost of giving a voucher to all of the roughly 300,000 children in Texas who already attend private schools. It isn't an opportunity for the 5.5 million children in Texas public schools. It is a theft of $545 per kid. It can be thought of as as a $13,000 pay cut for a teacher with 25 students in her class. Or perhaps the loss of an after-school program. Or new books. Or lunch.

Our enemies love the word "choice." They tell us we should be able to choose our doctors, but don't want us to be able to pay for our medical care, or even know what it will cost until we receive the bill. They tell us we should be able to choose our employment, but don't want us to choose what our employers pay us, or even to know what that will be before we apply for the job. They even want us to be able to choose which deodorant we use while selling us hundreds of brands, with different scents and different packaging, that all have the identical active ingredients. So why do our choices always turn out to benefit them?

Beware school choice.


* Note: Much of the data for this essay is from an article in this week's Texas Observer by Josephine Lee, "School Voucher Programs Are Hurting Special Needs Students They Claim to Help"

Wednesday, January 25, 2023

Federal Sales Tax

Back in the eighties I tried in my high school social studies classes to explain the difference between people who were living on income from work and people who were enriching themselves by the work of others. One of my activities was to ask the students to create budgets for families with incomes of $35,000 and families with incomes of $135,00. The first was still possible then. In fact it was close to what many of their own families made. The second seemed unimaginably large, to me as well as to them. With that fantasy $135,000 my students were able to splurge on nice homes, fancy cars, restaurants, theater and concert tickets, and elaborate vacations. The $35,000 went for rent, subway tokens, occasional trips to McDonald's and visits to family outside of New York. The realization that everything went to the same set of necessities was the point, because then we imagined a budget for a family making ten million a year. No matter how hard they tried, it was hard to spend more than a small percent of it.

This week the Republicans in Congress once again gutted the budget of the Internal Revenue Service. They have been doing this for decades. As a result, the IRS can't afford to audit the taxes of anybody but the poorest Americans. That is on top of the Reagan-era "reforms" that already lowered taxes on the wealthiest. But this year they also proposed replacing the income tax with a federal sales tax of roughly thirty percent.

We call a tax "progressive" when it increases the bite on those who can most afford it. Taking ten percent, say, from people who earn $50,000 leaves them with only $40,000, which is a significant change in their ability to survive. Taking fifty percent from people whose inheritance yields $10 million a year, on the other hand, still leaves them with a - to me - more-than-adequate $5 million a year.

A flat tax, on the other hand, taxes everybody the same. The Reagan reform called for a flat tax but settled for just dramatically compressing the difference between the highest and lowest tax rates. We call a flat tax "regressive" because it puts an unfair burden on the poor. If we tax everyone 20%, for example, that first family ends up with $30,000, which is unsupportable. But it leaves the rich family with $8 million a year, a gift from the poor of an addition $3 million.

That is what has been going on for the last forty years! Why are we surprised that the gap between the wealthiest Americans and everybody else has grown so much in that time? And they write checks to their representatives in Congress to ask for even more. This is even before we consider the fact that they're not being audited and that the tax code allows them write-offs to avoid paying any taxes at all.

So why did the Republican "Freedom" Caucus also suggest scrapping the income tax completely and replacing it with a 30% federal sales tax? Consider the social and economic arithmetic. The rule of thumb on rents and mortgages used to be that you shouldn't spend more than a quarter of your income on housing. That has been thrown out the window with rising housing costs and the average for working people is now about a third, with many paying even more. Let's pass that by without comment for now. It leaves our first family with $33,000 a year for everything else. If they spend it on necessities (which, of course, they must) it gets taxed, raising the cost to them by another $10,000 a year. However you parse this, it means either cutting their income to $22,000 or raising their expenses to $43,000 that they don't have.

And our second family? Well, again, they're mainly accumulating money; they're not actually spending more that a small percentage of the return on their wealth. consequently, that 30% tax is on a much smaller portion of their income, the part they're using on purchases. Even if we call that an extravagant million, the tax is now $300,000. This is a dramatic reduction (85% less!) even from the $2 million tax bill that we gave them with a very regressive flat tax above. Instead of the poor transferring $3 million a year to this wealthy family, the poor would now be responsible for a gift of almost $5 million.

If a flat income tax puts an unfair burden on those who can least afford it, then a flat sales tax is open robbery by the ultra-rich of everybody else. If a flat income tax is regressive, a federal sales tax is... I don't quite have a word strong enough.

There was never any chance such a sales tax would pass. The twenty Republicans who were holding up Kevin McCarthy's election as Speaker demanded a vote on it as one of the (many) concessions they extracted for their eventual support. He broke that promise immediately. It wouldn't have gained enough votes anyway. It certainly wouldn't have passed the Senate. So why bring it up?

Taking an extreme position and inserting it into the national consciousness is a way of moving the conversation in that direction. Ronald Reagan did not actually get a flat income tax. But by discussing it, our American oligarchs succeeded in changing the tax code to allow them to keep getting richer at our expense. The same strategy is moving us closer to gutting Social Security. Sometimes the tactic is to claim (falsely) that Social Security is bankrupting us. Sometimes it is to point at a bull stock market and con the gullible into thinking they could become rich if only they were investing their money instead of supporting their elders (who similarly supported their own elders throughout their entire working lives.) But whatever the short-term tactic, the long-term strategy is to end Social Security and impoverish the elderly. It may not happen today. It may not even happen totally. But the fact that we are discussing the previously unthinkable makes some part of it, at least, thinkable.

Our American reactionaries have motives of both ideology and greed for wanting to privatize everything, from highways to schools, from health care to policing. Their ideology of selfishness prevents them from seeing that there is any "we" at all. Why should anyone be responsible for anyone else's kids? Why should anyone be responsible for anyone else's medical crisis? But they also see a chance to cash in. House on fire? The privatized fire department pulls out a credit card reader before they connect their hoses and you're on the hook for a bill you simply cannot pay. Isn't that what the hospitals do already?

I write this only for myself, because nobody else will most probably ever see it. But I think about the people who proudly insist that they don't pay attention to politics. The man who encourages you to ignore politics has his hand in your pocket.

Monday, January 23, 2023

The Ban on AP African American History in Florida

 How to understand Florida’s ban on teaching Advanced Placed African American History? By seeing it in the context of other campaigns to enforce ignorance.


Way back in the 1950’s, when the cigarette manufacturers realized that their product was definitely killing people, they immediately began a propaganda campaign to discredit the science, to convince people that it was “debatable” instead of factual. They even made it a political issue with “I Smoke and I Vote!” bumper stickers.


Similarly, when the coal, oil, and natural gas companies realized that carbon dioxide from burning fossil fuels was, in fact, creating a massive climate crisis, they, too, immediately began a propaganda campaign. They hired ad agencies and fringe researchers to convince people that the existence of climate change was debatable. Then, when that became an untenable position, they pretended that it “wasn’t clear” whether it was caused by fossil-fuel burning instead of some as-yet-unknown “natural” process.


This highly-developed propaganda tactic relies on journalists’ professional obligation to present both sides of a story in order to spread ignorance instead of understanding. The problem is that there are no “two sides” to - for example - the existence of gravity or to the fact that the earth orbits the sun. There are also no “two sides” to whether cigarettes cause cancer or whether burning fossils fuels is causing our obvious climate crisis. These were conscious (and selfish) campaigns to promote ignorance of things that were already known in order to protect profits.


Now we see states passing laws to criminalize teaching in their schools. You read that right: criminalize teaching in schools. Among the best known are Florida’s Stop WOKE Act and Parental Rights Act. The first outlaws teaching that people in this country have been discriminated against because of their race, national origin, or gender! That is not my characterization; that is the language of the law itself. What adult doesn’t know that discrimination is a simple fact of the history of this country? But it is now illegal to teach that fact in Florida, and the law offers bounties to parents who turn their children’s teachers in for teaching that fact.


The second is popularly know as the “Don’t-Say-Gay" Act because it bans any discussion of gender or sexuality in the lower grades. It also forbids counselors and teachers in the upper grades from having conversations in confidence with individual students who want to talk about their sexuality or gender identity. It, too, offers bounties to parents who turn in their children’s teachers.


These Florida laws, and those like them in other states, go well beyond pretending that the existence of racism in the US (and the existence of different sexual orientations among human beings, always and everywhere) is controversial instead of factual. These laws criminalize teaching those facts. They represent an effort to outlaw the study of history and humanity. They say that the teaching of simple truth represents indoctrination and (that new favorite word of homophobes) “grooming.”


If there is anything positive about this horror it is the desperation it reveals. White supremacy tells on itself when frightened white parents say that don’t want their children to be traumatized by merely hearing about the dangers and indignities Black, Indigenous, Asian, and other historically-colonized people actually experience to this day. When Florida bans an advanced placement course from ETS they are working to keep information from the privileged children who are most likely to take those classes. The legislators aren’t just suppressing knowledge from the children of poor and working people; they are aggressively keeping it from their own children and the children of their wealthy donors. Hidden in this desperation is the fear that even the children of wealthy white families, recipients of all the privileges of racial capitalism, may turn against this oppressive and exploitive system if they learn how it works. 


We have to fight for the truth and fight for the obligation to teach the truth in the schools. We have to teach the truth to generations of teachers who never learned it when they were students and who suspect that it is historical “revisionism,” another of their scare words. And we have to challenge ourselves to learn it, too, instead of just treating the Stop WOKE and “Don’t-Say-Gay” Acts as just two more Florida Man jokes.

Saturday, November 12, 2022

What is a library?

Njamba abbreviated our walk in the woods at Orchard Beach this morning. We ended up hearing most of NPR's "On the Media." It was about libraries, starting with campaigns against libraries and librarians that are fueled by right-wing hysteria about grooming children by queer pedophiles. It got me thinking about the different ways we imagine libraries.

That campaign is mostly about public libraries, both community libraries and school libraries. I guess lots of people have early memories about libraries. I remember going through every child-directed biography in our school and public library. I remember reading about John Paul Jones, Ted Williams, Dwight Eisenhower, and Young Tom Edison. I remember reading history books for kids: We Were There with Jean Lafitte at New Orleans, We Were There with the Lafayette Espadrille, We Were There at the Boston Tea Party.

I also remember an unloved fifth-grade teacher who gave us a regular homework assignment of "study guides" on each of the fifty states. They were worksheets with spaces for us to fill in the area, population, principal industries, principal crops, etc. I found them grueling and sometimes impossible. We had an Information Please almanac at home, which provided some of the information. We also had an encyclopedia from 1938 that my grandpa purchased for my mom and my uncle, but let's just say that whatever information I could locate there was over twenty-five years out of date: Alaska and Hawaii weren't states in that book, there had been no Second World War, the population of California was 6 million instead of 18 million. One night I got permission to go to the public library to do that homework. (After school was not an option; it conflicted with Hebrew School.) It's only about a twenty-minute walk, but going out after dinner was a huge deal in my family. 

Anyway, I was astonished when the librarian directed me to the World Book Encyclopedia. Astonished because opposite every page with an entry about one of the US states was a table containing all the information I had been struggling to find to fill in Mr. Harris's stupid study guide. The exact format! The exact order! I knew that some of my classmates had that encyclopedia sitting in their rooms because I had seen it when I visited their homes. I was astonished because what had been a kind of unpleasant treasure hunt for me was clearly a simple and quick matter of copying some words and numbers for them. Looking back on this after forty years as an educator I am horrified by the lack of any intellectual content in fifty nights of this homework. But I am also horrified by an assignment that casually privileged children whose parents bought those (expensive! roughly $10,000 in 2022 dollars) 20+ volumes. I am not pleading poverty, but that was not something my parents were buying for us.

So this story serves in a way as a bridge between two ideas of the library. First, as a place where people can have access to books and what is in them for free, regardless of how much money they have. Second, as a place that stores and canonizes KNOWLEDGE. Think for a moment about a printed encyclopedia, whose editors decide what subjects deserve inclusion and what subjects do not. Who contract writers to give an authoritative account of those subjects, deciding what is true and what is not. The mere idea that a table including state bird, state tree, state song presents anything that helps us understand a state both flattens and trivializes what we think of as knowledge, turning learning into an accumulation of factoids. Why do we even have "state birds"? Why is the cardinal the state bird of seven different states? Does knowing that my state, New York, shares the Eastern Bluebird with Missouri add to my understanding of anything? 

And there is a conception of the library that shares this idea of complete, canonized knowledge with encyclopedias. The dream of a complete library goes back at least to Pharaoh Ptolemy I in the fourth century BCE. The library at Alexandria collected about half-a-million scrolls by means of purchase, confiscation, and theft in order to achieve the Pharaoh's goal of possessing every book ever. The idea continued in the science fiction of the 20th century and has received new impetus with the existence of an internet. I read a short story once about a PhD candidate of the future whose dissertation work consisted only of trying to come up with a project that nobody else had done already. An original project could be completed instantly by using the all-knowing computer, but an original idea was also vanishingly rare. This idea suggests that all human knowledge is finite. It also suggests that anything worth knowing can, in fact be known. It says that maybe we humans don't yet know everything, and maybe we individuals can't know everything known by humanity, but individuals can at least have access to everything that humanity knows. I think even that is wrong, because it assumes that the things we think we (individuals, experts, humanity as a whole) "know" are in fact true. 

There is a third understanding of library, which bleeds into the word archive. It includes not just every book, but every piece of paper. Today it would include everything that has ever been typed onto a computer: every job application, every snarky Tweet, every photo of lunch, every text message asking "WYD?" A friend's dad once showed me his basement, which was filled end-to-end and floor-to-ceiling with library shelving. On the shelves was every invoice and every bill of sale from his business, every gas and electric bill from his home, his and his children's report cards... I struggled to figure out whether all of this could ever have any value. When he gave up his home for an apartment it was all moved into a rental storage unit. Now, less than a year from his death in his late nineties it will be up to his children to see if they want to keep some of it, and how to dispose of the rest.

But every archive cannot be dismissed as hoarding. When I looked into the ongoing struggle of the Lakota over the Black Hills, (see for instance "The Black Hills Are Not for Sale" and "Still More: Treaty Rights") I was able to obtain a photocopy of the minutes of a 1920 meeting of tribal leaders initiating the lawsuit that remains unresolved today, despite the Supreme Court's 1980 decision in United States v. Sioux Nation of Indians, 448 U.S. 371 It showed a very different set of conversations than I would have imagined. Those minutes were being held in the library of Oglala Lakota College in Kyle, South Dakota. Shortly after the librarian generously sent me this document, the library was threatened by unusual spring floods, the result of sudden warm temperatures after an exceptionally snowy winter. I sent a donation of thanks, in part because I imagined the destruction of that archive.

When I looked into resistance to the draft during World War 1, I was able to get digitized records of inmates at Leavenworth Penitentiary. (See "Green Corn Rebellion" and "More On the Green Corn Rebellion.") Looking at the prison records of participants in this armed march against the war, including their friends and family who were authorized to correspond with them by mail, allowed me to see what connections did (and did not) exist among the rebels. This is important to understand given the multiracial nature of the uprising in Oklahoma, including Blacks, whites, and Natives in roughly equal numbers.

The flip side of this is the archives that have vanished in fires and floods. Genealogists all know, for example, that the rolls of the 1890 census are largely gone, damaged by a 1921 fire in the basement of the US Department of Commerce. In fact, that fire is largely responsible for the creation of the National Archives. But when I was looking into property records in so many places around the US, I was surprised to find how many of them had been destroyed. And I cannot help but suspect that much of this was intentional. So much land belonging to African Americans, Mexican Americans, Native Americans, and Asian Americans somehow ended up in the hands of their white neighbors over the course of time. It is hard for me to imagine that the repeated pattern of disappearing paper records, records that would document the real owners, was all accidental. It is just too convenient.

But let me return to the current campaigns against libraries. They are not particularly new, just accelerating. Efforts to ban books have been an American perennial, documented year after year by the American Library Association. There are those who want the Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels to be removed from the shelves. I guess these people really don't believe their own rhetoric about the undeniable superiority of capitalism because they are apparently afraid that if somebody reads this 1848 pamphlet our entire economic and social system will be endangered. 

I am a little puzzled by the endless campaign against the Captain Underpants series. For those of you who have no preteens in your life these books are the ongoing saga of resistance by two fourth-grade class clowns against their mean principal. I guess there are people who feel the premise is too disrespectful and antiauthoritarian. Again, is our civilization really so fragile that it is imperiled by a bunch of nine-year-olds chuckling about the pranks of George and Harold?

Catcher in the Rye? Centers a teenage slacker who questions everything. 

Are You There, God? It's Me Margaret? Frank discussion of menstruation. (If we don't say it aloud will it stop?)

The Things They Carried? I don't know; insufficiently worshipful of war and warriors?

To Kill a Mockingbird? You already know. Even this white savior narrative is too explicit about the horrors of racism.

But that is the bridge to the current attacks on libraries. Because a number of state legislators, challenged to say where they saw critical race theory being taught in the public schools, immediately pointed to To Kill a Mockingbird. It is easy to see that "Critical Race Theory" was coded language for the racist right. It is an approach to understanding the way white supremacy is cooked into law, without necessarily being mentioned explicitly. It is offered as an elective in some law schools, not mandated in grade school curricula. But the language that is used to criminalize it is revealing. Parents are urged to report anything taught in school that makes their children "uncomfortable." And you can definitely read that sentence as "white parents" and "white children." All the examples raised by the politicians riding this hysteria are about white children who are learning for the first time about the history of enslavement and Jim Crow and finding it horrifying. None of those examples are about Black or Latino or Native or Asian children who are othered by their teachers and administrators. And the books these parents want removed are by Toni Morrison and Ta-Nahisi Coates and Sherman Alexie. I am prepared to defend the value of that literature as part of a mandatory curriculum. But they are apparently prepared to demand that brilliant literature - literature that is written by people who aren't white and offers a different point-of-view - be banned from library shelves.

It is also definitely worth noticing that these campaigns only pretend to be grassroots phenomena, instigated by parents who are disturbed by their children's reaction to what they have been taught. Take Boundary County, Idaho. Angry citizens there are demanding the recall of the library board and they have presented a list of 300 books that must be removed. The head librarian quit her job after endless death threats and armed protesters parked outside her house night after night. But the library never owned any of those three hundred books!

Most of this list represents a new tack by the enemies of literature. They're not so prudish as to oppose any reference to sexuality, only to the sexuality of LGBTQ people! But their argument is the same as the opposition to the Communist Manifesto and Captain Underpants. It is still the danger of such exposure. They insist that children can "turn gay" by reading about gay people. They accuse the librarians of grooming. 

I will not dismiss the need for parents to safeguard their children against pedophile adults. We have all seen the scandals of pedophile priests and clergy in all denominations. We have seen the Boy Scouts of America file for bankruptcy because of the weight of sex abuse cases. I will remind you that most groomers, like most people, are heterosexual. I will ask why you think heterosexual children can be groomed to become gay by reading stories about gay people, but all these gay people failed to "turn straight" despite reading and viewing endless stories about straight people. I will also remind you that these people believe that their fourth grader is being groomed by Harold because at the end of Captain Underpants and the Sensational Saga of Sir Stinks-A-Lot it is revealed that he will grow up to have a male domestic partner. I will remind you that they also believe that every Hollywood star and Democratic politician is part of a vast conspiracy to cannibalize children. I will remind you that nobody can point to where all these disappeared children came from.

So is this really about grooming? Or is somebody using parents' fears of predatory pedophiles for some other agenda? And is white supremacy the only reason for attacks on libraries that actually stock antiracist literature? Or is it also a helpful fear that provides racist cover for another agenda entirely, one that many of these racists wouldn't support if it traveled under its own name?

Let's go back to that episode of "On the Media" that we heard because Njamba didn't really feel like walking in the woods this morning. The host interviewed Emily Drabinski, who is the interim chief librarian at the CUNY Graduate Center and the president-elect of the American Library Association. Drabinski apparently made herself a lightning rod for all this anti-librarian venom by posting a celebratory tweet about her election as a Marxist lesbian. But she argues, and I agree, that underlying the opposition to libraries is an opposition to public institutions. Remember that World Book Encyclopedia that I eventually accessed at the library? Without libraries the only children who could use that encyclopedia would be those whose parents paid for it. The history of public libraries in this country, like the history of public schools, goes back to the earliest trade union movement. Both were demands that learning be made available to people who could afford to pay for it. There were no public schools at all in most of the states controlled by enslavers before the Civil War. Public schools in the former Confederacy were begun by the Reconstruction legislatures, the program of formerly-enslaved people. Segregated schools weren't a means of separating Black children from white children; they were a means of denying education to Black children. 

In 1959 the white librarian in Lake City, South Carolina called the police on nine-year-old Ronald McNair because he wanted to borrow books. Yes, that Ronald McNair. The one who earned a PhD from MIT. The one who served as an astronaut on the Space Shuttle Challenger in 1984. The one who died in 1986 when the Challenger disintegrated over the Atlantic Ocean. That library is now named after Ronald McNair. But the campaign to defund libraries will prevent another Ronald McNair from reading the books about space that he wants.

Privatization as an ideology argues that the profit motive ensures better services for us all, an argument without evidence that amounts to a quasi-religious faith. Privatization as a practice allows profiteers to step in and provide (or pretend to) services while exploiting every shortcut imaginable to maximize their returns. But privatization as a political strategy is a way for the wealthy to shed any public responsibility at all. Why pay for schools that my child won't attend? Why pay for airline inspection when I'm hiring my own pilot to fly my own plane? Why pay to keep libraries open when I buy the books I want and profit more when you all have to buy your own, too?

There are exceptions. The fire service used to be private. If you paid a subscription in advance, the firefighters would come to put water on your house. But it turns out that fire doesn't discriminate between subscribers and non-subscribers and if your neighbor's home was fully engulfed in flames, yours was going up, too. So the fire department became a public service, paid for by all our taxes. Policing is a different kind of public service. Yes, the rich still maintain their own private security, but they can also tax us to provide a police force that protects them from the rest of us.

But they have very little interest in our education, beyond training us to work for them and produce their profits. When you see some hack demanding to know why we teach science instead of how to fill out credit card applications, remember that they want us to be climate skeptics so that they can keep profiting on both the destruction of our planet and our need to pay usurious interest to them. When you see them mocking the study of history, remember that they really don't want us to know any. In the days of Jim Crow, white exploiters didn't want their Black workers able to read contracts or calculate rent and debt. How different do you think the capitalists of today are? The entire charter school scam is the latest trick to defund and dismantle public education. And the idea that librarians are grooming our children to be gay?

Wake up.

Monday, October 3, 2022

Satan?

 Florida Governor Rick DeSantis is not Satan. He is a human man.

When he was a Member of the US House of Representatives in 2013, he did try to deny federal disaster relief to victims of Superstorm Sandy here in New York and New Jersey. Because he wanted to pretend he’s a fiscal conservative? Because we tend to vote for Democrats? Because he believes there is no “we, the people” so everyone is responsible for their own hardships?


In the aftermath of Hurricane Ian he is insisting that it was a “500-year storm.” Why? It is definitely the strongest to hit Florida in the last four years, since Michael in 2018, which came with 160 mph winds and killed 50. Does he want us to think it’s a statistical freak instead of the utterly predictable result of human-caused global warming? Does he want to justify his request for federal relief for Florida, but not for New Jersey and New York? Does he want to pretend that there won’t be another, maybe even during this hurricane season?


He is also defending the decision of officials in Lee County, the hardest-hit area, not to evacuate before the storm. Does he really think this should be an individual decision, placing the lives and safety of first responders at the whim of the folks they will be forced to rescue (or recover)? Is he so dependent on the political support of county officials who made a bad call that he can’t antagonize them? Does he simply not care about the people who lost their lives?


And then there are the Venezuelan refugees he kidnapped from Texas and flew to Massachusetts as a political stunt. The original plan was apparently to fly migrants from Florida but there were political costs to that idea. So he sent agents 700 miles and four states away, with false promises of jobs and homes, to lure desperate people out from under the eye of Texas Governor Greg Abbott. Abbott is DeSantis’s rival to be the Republican Presidential candidate in 2024, and he has been stunting with migrants, too... although with buses, not airplanes; and with major Northern cities, not resort islands. I don’t even have to speculate about motives: DeSantis clearly believes that his political ambitions outweigh both the humanity of the people he kidnapped and the Florida law that set aside funds for him to transport migrants out of Florida, not random other states. He clearly resented Greg Abbott’s access to people whose humanity neither of them recognize.


So, back to Satan. No, Rick DeSantis is not him. But Rick DeSantis willingly volunteers - again and again and again - to do his work. 

Tuesday, September 13, 2022

No, we are not all in the same boat

 Judith is not the only Black woman I know who finally couldn't keep watching "A Handmaid's Tale" on TV. The reminders of their great-grandmothers' experiences, the notion that this all becomes a horror because it's happening to white women, the belief that this is speculative fiction instead of fact... it was all too much. The use of the red, hooded cloaks as a public trope made it more than just a show to stop watching. Protests against Trump's inauguration, against misogynist Supreme Court nominees, and finally against the Court's long-prepared blow against women's bodily autonomy in Dobbs v. Mississippi all featured demonstrators in those cloaks. The implication that this represents a frightening future instead of a horrifying past is a kind of color blindness that erases the historical memory of Black and Native women and presents white experience as universal instead of particular.

There are parallels all over the landscape of political issues in the US. Every time a white person responds to the latest horror with an indignant "This is not who we are!" Black people roll their eyes and say "This is who you always were." An attempted insurrection and coup at the US Capitol in 2021? A successful murderous insurrection and coup in Wilmington, North Carolina in 1898. Separating parents from their children at the border? The entire history of Native boarding schools and the present practices of child welfare agencies with Black families. Mass shootings of Mexican and Mexican Americans in El Paso and African Americans in Buffalo? Do I even need to say anything?

I was caught off guard by discussions of a post-apocalyptic novel by Rebecca Roanhorse. She made the point that Native people are already living in post-apocalyptic times, something that I had failed up until that moment to fully register. Similarly, Black, Native, and other colonized American peoples have already experienced fascism. Way back in 1946, when most people in the US were still freshly horrified by the full exposure of the extremes of the Nazi holocaust, WEB DuBois wrote in The World and Africa:

There was no Nazi atrocity - concentration camps, wholesale maiming and murder, defilement of women and ghastly blasphemy of childhood - which the Christian civilization of Europe had not long been practicing against colored folk in all parts of the world in the name of and for the defense of a Superior Race born to rule the world.

This is actually the meaning of the descriptor "racial capitalism." It isn't a "flavor" of capitalism, like mercantile or monopoly. It is essential to exploitation to target a group that the exploiter can dismiss as somehow lesser, somehow less deserving to be treated as kin or even as human. But the dirty secret is that whatever a capitalist tries against another color or nationality or religion will - sooner than later - be extended against people whose only real difference is less money.

White people often object to discussion of difference. They may say that it weakens unity. But imagine how hard it must be to find unity with people who refuse even to acknowledge your lived experience.